Saturday, July 11, 2020
«« »»
Artist: Rapoon (@)
Title: What Do You Suppose? (The Alien Question) / Project Blue Book
Format: CD
Label: Zoharum (@)
Distributor: Alchembria
Rated: *****
This new reissue from Zoharum is another classic from Rapoon dated 1999. "What Do You Suppose? (The Alien Question)" is a concept album based on the theories related to aliens and their presence on the planet made by William Cooper so the texts of the various tracks, rather to be an esthetic element, are the focus of this release and made it a really different from the previous reissues.
The loop from an old record and the spoken word of "Before I Begin" opens this release as a quiet introduction to the beat of "Waddi Haj" where the ethnic elements of his music return while "How Many of You Understand?" is based on the words and "Never Called NJ12'¦" is finally the juxtaposition of the two musical elements. "Give Us Dub" is, as the title suggests, a dub influenced bridge to the second part of this album starting with "No Really'¦" where the dialogue introduces an emerging loop.
"How Many of You Did Not Know That?" is a long cinematic track focused on a drone. The deep drone of "The Alien Question" is frightening in opposition to the "Only The Names Change"'s one. "Without Aliens'¦" is a meditative track based on a vocal loop and a drone while "I Don't Expect Anyone'¦" closes this release returning to the classic rhythmic structure of this project.
The second CD is a complete rework of the original release removing the spoken word part, with the exception of "The Truth Regarding UFO's", and focusing on the rhythmic element so tracks like "Further than Waddi Haj", based upon "Waddi Haj", "Leaving Us", based upon "I Don't Expect Anyone'¦", or "Send Dub", based upon "Give Us Dub", sound like experiments in sound nuances. The other tracks removes the cinematic elements that are peculiar of the original release and replaces them with dance oriented ones; the only exception is "Dark Gods Breathing" focusing on tone oriented chant.
While the first CD could stand among the finest releases of Robin Storey with his remarkable shift upon a narrative element usually absent in the previous releases, the bonus disc sounds more like the usual add-on of a reissue or a variation on the form already exposed in his classic masterpiece. However, this is an essential reissue.


< Previous Review | Next Review >